Wednesday, June 6, 2012


Assignment 3.3 Blog Post:  Technology—Friend or Foe of Education?


Victor Hugo ROJAS B. made an interesting post to his blog, victorhugor, on July 28, 2009, entitled “The Networked Teacher of the 21st Century”.  He referred to educators as Networked Teachers due to the fact that they maintain blogs, wikis, video-conferences, social networking, and various other technology-based tools for interactive teaching and learning. He maintained that personality and teaching styles are not enough to consider an educator well-rounded; technology must be integrated into a teacher’s daily routine. My question:  Is technology a friend or foe of education?


Technology is beneficial to education in countless ways. My personal favorite is the online classroom. Since January 2006, I have earned a 2-year certificate of completion in Office Management, an A.A.S. degree in Information Technology, and I’m working on a BS in Adult Education; I have had only three classes in a traditional classroom. Online classes enable students who would otherwise be unable to attend college due to job, family, and other obligations or restrictions earn a degree. We have soldiers all over the world (and on ships and submarines) that take classes.


Technology is also a great study aid for students. Word processing software is much easier than pen and paper. Information on any topic is at their fingertips in seconds! Nowadays, they don’t even need a computer—just a cell phone. Gone are the days spending hours at the library poring over books and encyclopedias. Students can even purchase an eBook instead of a paper textbook.  


Technology and computers are a big help to instructors also. There are endless resources and instructional aids available online. Need a video to demonstrate a task? Try YouTube.  Have a student that just doesn’t seem to learn from your lectures? Check out tips for visual learning styles. Speaking of learning styles, computers can be used to provide lessons that would be suitable for different styles. The teacher can present a colorful PowerPoint that incorporates pictures and graphs, narration, and written bullets. Students can read information on the computer, or listen to tutorials and lectures, or watch a demonstration.


So it looks like technology in education is perfect, right? Not quite. Like most arguments, there are two sides. Consider this sentence: “My too friends went two the store to get gifts fore they’re dads.”  Isn’t Spellcheck great! I have noticed that some students rely on it a little too much.  And as much as I love online classes, I cannot tell you how many times I have been stressed and frustrated because I could not access class or do research for an assignment because the Internet was not working. And yes, the computer is a great research tool; but I have noticed that students “working” in the classroom aren’t always working on assignments.


There are several articles available online about texting affecting communication skills, spelling skills, and writing skills. I chose to read Texting Affects Communication Skills” by Superintendent A. Barbara Wheeler of Kent Count Public Schools. She points out that while technology has some positive aspects, there are also negative aspects: children playing video games and texting instead of physical activity outside; children (and adults) texting each other (in the same room) instead of having actual conversations; parents not communicating with their children face to face; and the destruction of the English language with LOL, OMG, where r u, etc. The article ends with this statement, “Our challenge in school, as well as at home, is not to fight technology because it is here to stay; but school personnel will play a critical role in channeling technology in the direction of quality teaching and learning. Parents must insist that children understand the appropriate use of technology and the significant impact that poor judgment can cause.” I think that statement perfectly sums up how technology should be considered by educators. You can read the entire article at: http://www.kent.k12.md.us/index.php?otion=com_content&view=article&id=555:texting-affects-communication-skills&catid=54:superintendent&ltemid=188.

5 comments:

  1. The quote "channeling technology" makes a lot of sense to me, Jan. We need to use the technology available to us and you make a good point that students working in the classroom aren't always working on assignments. The computer is a great tool for accessing knowledge but it is also the source of fun and games. Using technology to learn takes discipline on the side of the learner and creativity on the side of the educator.

    Cute commentary on technology - my two year old grandson asked for my phone recently. When I asked him who he was going to call, he said: No call! Wes plays apps.
    We need to keep up! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Be Realistic, Cindy! There is no way we can keep up with a two-year old!

      Delete
  2. HI Jan,

    I am so glad that you brought this subject up on your blog. As a a student I am amazed at how much I can learn and accomplish with technology by my side but like you mentioned we do need to be careful not to become too dependent on it.

    A couple of years ago I took a couple of math classes and my experience with the online resources I was given was just awesome. We used an online program called My math lab. I loved it because I felt like I had tutor right there next to me as I worked through every homework problem. If ever I got stuck or needed to look something up it I had the information near by so I could move forward quickly. I also learned a ton because the program would instantly give me feedback if I made a mistake. I did not miss one second of writing out my Math problems with paper and pencil nor did I miss turning in my homework only to discover that I was going about something incorrectly a week or two later when my assignment was returned.

    On the other hand, I did learn, like you explained in your blog post, that I needed to discipline myself from becoming too dependent on the tool itself. I noticed as I took my midterm for my first class that I was wishing for the "help me" button when I got stuck. After that I learned to balance using the tool with good old fashioned paper and pencil practice before tests.

    I think that this subject really brings to the light the dramatic differences between Early childhood education and adult education as this balance between technology and choosing the most effect way to learn or prepare is a difficult one. I also think that this topic speaks to the the fact that as students as well as future adult educators we need to be willing to search for the best method of teaching or learning rather than, like I originally did in my math class, cling to what we find works easiest for us.

    Thank you for such a thought provoking post!

    Becca

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  3. Hello Becca,
    I really appreciate your comment; I'm very happy you could relate to my post. I had a math class that used that same math lab, and I know exactly what you mean!It was very convenient as long as you didn't grow too dependant on it!

    ReplyDelete